$B!!(J

NO.45$B!J(J2006$BG/(J09$B7n!K(J



$B@8J*652J=q$N%_%9%F%j!<(J$B!J(J1$B!K(J
$B!!!=%X%C%1%k$N%K%;$Nfu$O$J$<652J=q$+$i>C$($J$$$+!=(J

$B$$$C$?$$$J$

$B!!@$$NCf$K$O!V$$$C$?$$$J$Z5r!W$N0l$D$H$7$F@8J*$N652J=q$K:\$C$F$$$k!"$"$NC/$K$G$b3P$($N$"$k%X%C%1%k$Nfu$NHf3S3($b!"$^$5$K$=$&$$$&$b$N$N0l$D$G$"$k!#$3$N0l7o$K$D$$$FD4$Y$l$PD4$Y$k$[$I!"$=$NM}IT?T$5$K2f!9$O@d6g$9$k!#$=$NL@Gr$JHH:aE*56B$!"$=$l$,J,$+$C$F$$$J$,$i0l@$5*0J>e$K$o$?$C$F652J=q$,$3$l$rMxMQ$7$F$-$?$3$H$NIT2D2r$H$=$NHH:a@-!=!=$3$l$,Nr;K652J=qLdBj$NHf$G$"$k$+$J$$$+!"!VHH:a@-!W$H$$$&$N$,8XD%$G$"$k$+$J$$$+!";d$N@bL@$r:G8e$^$GFI$s$G$$$?$@$$$F=t7;;P$N$4H=CG$r6D$.$?$$!#(J
$B!!K:$l$F$J$i$J$$$3$H$O!"9b9;$G!V@8J*!W$rJY6/$9$k3X@8$N05E]E*B??t$O!"@8J*3Xo<1!W$H$7$F5[<}$7!"@8$-$F$$$/>e$G$=$l$i$rL50U<1$NH=CG$N$h$9$,$H$9$k!W$N5!G=$r;}$D$N$G$"$k!#(J
$B!!:#;d$NJF2!"$J!V8DBNH/@8$O7OE}H/@8$r7+$jJV$9!W$H$$$&!VK!B'!W$K2?$i$+$N7A$G8@5Z$7$F$$$k!#@bL@J8$NJ}$O!"$+$J$jBgC@$K$3$l$r??M}$H$7$F2r@b$9$k$b$N!"8@MU$rBy$7$FCGDj$rHr$1$k$b$N$H!"B?>/$N:9$O$"$k$,K\

$B!V8DBN$NH/@82aDx$r@8J*$N4V$GHf3S$9$k$H!"$=$N=i4|$N7ABV$,$h$/;w$F$$$k$3$H$,$"$k!#Nc$($P!"%R%H$NB[;y$K$brT!J$($i!K$dHx$KAjEv$9$k$H9M$($i$l$k9=B$$,8=$l$k!#$3$l$b!"@8J*$,6&DL(J $B$NAD@h$+$i?J2=$7$?$3$H$r<($9>Z5r$H9M$($i$l$k!#!W!JEl5~=q@R!K(J


$B!V@TDGF0J*$NH/@82aDx$rHf3S$9$k$H=i4|$Nfu$O$h$/;w$F$$$k!#@TDGF0J*$N=i4|$Nfu$G$O!"6&DL(J $B$KrT$N$"$J$N$/$\$_$,=P8=$9$k$,!"$=$N?t$OF0J*72$K$h$C$F0[$J$j!D!W!J;0>JF2!K(J

$B!!A0 $B!!$3$l$r%^%$%1%k!&%j%A%c!<%I%=%s$K$h$k8=$BITE,$B!W!=!=$b;2>H$5$l$?$$!#!V=i4|$N7ABV!W$H$$$&$3$H<+BN$,4V0c$$$@$HH`$O;XE&$9$k!#!K(J

$BF|K\$N@8J*$N652J=q$K:\$;$i$l$F$$$k%X%C%1%k$Nfu$N?^!#>e$+$i=g$K!"El5~=q@R!";0>JF2!"

$B!!%j%A%c!<%I%=%s<+?H!"!V%X%C%1%k$,Gr>u$7$F$$$k$K$b$+$+$o$i$:!"!D$=$N3($OB8B3$7$F$$$k!#$3$l$3$=K\Ev$N%_%9%F%j!<$@!W$H8@$C$F$$$k$H$$$&!J(JNew Scientist, 9/6/97$B!K!#H`$O$^$?$3$&$b8@$C$F$$$k!=!=!V$3$l$O2J3X3&$N56B$$N:G0-$N$b$N$N0l$D$@!#0NBg$J2J3X

$BCQ$:$Y$-$3$H(J

$B!!;d$,D4$Y$?$+$.$j!"%@!<%&%#%K%9%H$b4^$a$FC/0l?M$H$7$F!"%X%C%1%k$N!V=i4|$Nfu!W$N3(!JHG2h!K$KLdBj$,$J$$$H8@$C$F$$$k@lLg$N3XZL@$7$h$&$H$7$?$3$H$O@5$7$$!J$+$i5v$5$l$k!K!W$H$$$&$3$H$G$"$k!##P!&#Z!&%^%$%d!<%:$7$+$j!"H?#I#D$NF.;N%f!<%8%'%K!R2p$7$?!#(J
$B!!7+$jJV$78@$&$,!"@8J*$N652J=q$r3X$V

$B!J8=:_$b652J=q$K;H$o$l$F$$$k!K(JHaeckel$B!J(J1874$B!K$N%K%;$Nfu$N3(!JHG2h!K$H(JMichael Richardson$B!J(J1997$B!K$K$h$k8=

$B!!!V%_%9%F%j! $B!!$7$+$7E/3X$,2?$G$"$l!"L5?@O@$G$"$m$&$HM-?@O@$G$"$m$&$H!"@8J*3X$,2J3X$G$"$k0J>e!"%G!<%?$r$$$8$C$F$O$$$1$J$$$N$G$O$J$$$+!"$;$a$F:G?7$N@53N$Jl9g!"GX$KJ"$OBe$($i$l$J$$$H$$$&;v>p$,%@!<%&%#%K%9%H$K$O$"$k!#$b$7!"$9$Y$F$NF0J*$K$D$$$F$[$H$s$I0c$o$J$$$H$$$&!V=i4|$Nfu!W$r!"%j%A%c!<%I%=%s$NC$($k$@$m$&!#$=$l$G$O!"6&DL(J $B@hAD@b$r>ZL@$7$h$&$H$7$F$3$l$r9M$(=P$7$?%X%C%1%k$N0U?^$=$N$b$N$,H]Dj$5$l$k!#$+$D$F?M4V$K$bB>$NF0J*$K$bF1MM$K!"5{$N!J$h$&$J!K;~Be$,$"$j!"Hx$r;}$D;~Be$,$"$C$?$H$$$&$?$a$K$O!"%X%C%1%k$N3($G$J$1$l$P$J$i$J$$$N$G$"$k!#(J
$B!!$G$O$3$l$r!"@8J*3X;K>e$N$+$D$F$N6=L#$"$k0l@b$H$7$F>R2p$9$l$P$I$&$J$N$+!#$=$l$J$iA4$/LdBj$O$J$$!#$7$+$7$=$l$G$O%@!<%&%#%K%9%H$O>5CN$G$-$J$$!#%X%C%1%k$N!VH/@8H?I|@b!W!"$"$k$$$O!V@8J*H/@8$NK!B'!W(Jbiogenetic law$B$HH`$N8F$s$@$b$N$O!"@8$-$?8=

$B:vKEE*;WA[2H(J

$B!!%@!<%&%#%K%:%`$,$=$N5=bVE*!&1#JCE*BN $B!!$3$NK\$O!"%@!<%&%#%s?J2=O@$+$i%R%H%i!<$N%J%A%:%`$K;j$k;WA[$N7OIh$r@WIU$1$?$b$N$G$"$k$,!"0l6e@$5*Kv$+$iFs$D$N@$3&Bg@o$K;j$k%I%$%D$rCf?4$H$9$kB?$/$N$3$NN.$l$N;WA[2H$NCf$G!":G$bCf?4E*$JLr3d$r1i$8$F$$$k$N$O%X%C%1%k$G$"$k$H8@$C$F$h$$$@$m$&!#$3$&$$$C$?;qNA$+$iIb$+$S>e$,$k%X%C%1%kA|$O!"05E]E*$K:vKEE*;WA[2H!":vF02H$H$7$F$N$=$l$G$"$C$F!"NI?4E*2J3X $B!!$"$k%$%s%?!<%M%C%H%5%$%H$O$3$&>R2p$7$F$$$k!=!=(J

$B!!%(%k%s%9%H!&%X%C%1%k$O$A$g$&$I%O!<%P!<%H!&%9%Z%s%5!<$N$h$&$K!"4V0c$C$F$$$F$b0zMQ$5$l0W$$8@MU$r;D$7$?!#:G$bM-L>$J$N$O!V8DBNH/@8$O7OE}H/@8$r7+$jJV$9!W$H$$$&$b$N$G$"$k$,!"H`$O$^$?(Jphylum$B!"(Jphylogeny$B!"(Jecology$B$H$$$C$?!":#F|!"@8J*3X$GIaDL(J $B$K;H$o$l$kB?$/$N8@MU$r$bB$8l$7$?!#$^$?0lJ}$G%X%C%1%k$O!"%J%A%9$N@kEA$K$h$/MxMQ$5$l$?!V@/<#3X$H$O1~MQ@8J*3X$G$"$k!W$H$$$&8@MU$b;D$7$?!#%J%AE^$OIT9,$J$3$H$K!"%X%C%1%k$NJ86g$@$1$G$J$/!"L1B2H1~4X78$O$J$$$3$H$r>ZL@$7$?!#!J(Jwww.ucmp.berkely.edu/history/haeckel.html$B!K(J

$B!!$^$?(JRussell Grigg$B$H$$$&?M$K$h$k%5%$%H!"!V%(%k%s%9%H!&%X%C%1%k!=!=?J2=O@$N@k65$G$"$k!W$H8@$$!"?J2=$KBP$9$kLU?.$N$"$^$j!"F,$G9M$($?$b$N$K9g$o$;$F>Z5r$rYTB$$7$?Nc$H$7$F!"!V%b%M%i!W$H$$$&L5@8J*$H@8J*$r$D$J$0@8J*$r$b$C$H$b$i$7$/$G$C$A$2!"2J3X;(;o$KH/I=$7$F!"D9G/$K$o$?$C$F@$4V$r$@$^$7B3$1$?;vNc$r$"$2$F$$$k!#(J

$B!N$7$+$7!O%X%C%1%k$N2x$7$2$J3hF0$NCf$G:G$bM-L>$J!"$"$k$$$O:G$b0-L>9b$$$N$O!"?M4V$Nfu$OB>$NS.F}F0J*$HF1$8$/!":G=i!"5{$N$h$&$JrT$r;}$A!"$d$,$F%5%k$N$h$&$J?,Hx$r;}$D0lO"$NCJ3,$r7P2a$9$k$N$@$H$$$&!"A4$/8m$C$?@b$rN.I[$5$;$?$3$H$G$"$k!#(J

$B!!H`$OFs?M$NB>$N2J3X5=E*$K2~JQ$7$FNc$Nfu$N3($r56B$$7!"Cx=q(JNatüliche Schöfungs-geschichte$B!J!XAOB$$N<+A3;K!Y!"0lH,O;H,!K$K:\$;$?$N$@$,!"Ev;~%i%$%W%D%#%RBg3X$NM-L>$JHf3SH/@83X

$B!V;d$Nfu$N3($N$o$:$+$NItJ,!J$*$=$i$/I4$N$&$AO;$D$+H,$D!K$O@b$K$h$C$F%.%c%C%W$rKd$a!"Hf3SE*Am9g$K$h$C$F7g=j$r:F9=C[$9$k$[$+$J$$$N$G!"$=$N$h$&$K$7$?$b$N$@!#$3$N;E;v$,$$$+$K:$Fq$G$"$k$+!"?^9)

$BCx $B!!$3$3$+$i$D$J$,$C$F$$$/652J=q$N%_%9%F%j!<$r2r$/$K$O!"$=$7$F%X%C%1%k!&%@!<%&%#%K%:%`$NK\Ev$N62$m$7$5$rJ,$+$C$F$b$i$&$K$O!"99$K9F$r=E$M$J$1$l$P$J$i$J$$!#(J

$B!X@$3&;WA[!Y(JNo.371$B!J(J2006$BG/(J9$B7n9f!K(J

$B!C(J$B?M4V86M}$NC55a(JI$B#N#D#E#S(J$B!C(J$BA0$NO@J8(J$B!C(J$B$B!C(J


$BAOB$%G%6%$%s3X2q!!")(J107-0062$B!!El5~ET9A6hFn@D;3(J6-12-3-903$B!!(J